
Photos by Teresa Sargeant; Teresa Sargeant; Dana O’Connor
Key Points
- The Apopka City Commission voted 4-1 to reject contracts for three department heads after debating severance and retiree health benefits.
- The contracts offered up to 20 weeks of base pay for dismissal without cause, about $77,200 for Hippler and $69,200 each for Rivera-Sanchez and Brooks.
- - Mayor Nick Nesta dissented, saying the contracts would help recruit and retain directors by offering financial protection if politics influenced a dismissal.
The Apopka City Commission voted 4-1 on Wednesday to reject employment contracts for three department heads after commissioners raised concerns about severance costs and retiree health benefits. Mayor Nick Nesta cast the lone dissenting vote.
The Wednesday meeting agenda recommended the commission approve agreements for Information Technology Director Robert Hippler, Fire Chief Wilfredo Rivera-Sanchez and Utilities Operations Director Glen Brooks. Commissioner Nadia Anderson moved to deny the contracts, and Commissioner Sam Ruth seconded the motion. The commission ratified Hippler’s appointment on Nov. 6.
Nesta cited Section 3.03 of Apopka’s city charter, which requires a majority vote at a regularly scheduled commission meeting to approve employment contracts and any extensions, modifications, amendments or rescissions.
The proposed agreements specified at-will employment with no fixed end date. They provided for up to 20 weeks of base salary if the city fired a department head without cause and the employee met the agreements’ conditions, including signing and delivering a release of claims within 60 days.
Under Section 215.425(4)(a) of the Florida Statutes, severance pay under a government employment contract is capped at 20 weeks of compensation. The law also bars such payments for employees fired for misconduct as defined by state law.
At the salaries listed in the proposals, 20 weeks of base pay would amount to about $77,200 for Hippler and $69,200 each for Rivera-Sanchez and Brooks.
Nesta said the agreements would help recruit and retain directors by offering financial protection if politics influenced a dismissal. He said a candidate for the vacant community development director position was uncomfortable relocating for an at-will job given the city’s political climate.
“They should be for the residents and not on anybody’s side, just doing what’s right,” Nesta said of the directors.
Ruth questioned why the proposals called for up to 20 weeks of severance.
“I think only the city administrator ought to be extended the formal contract,” Ruth said. “If every department head is apolitical, politics shouldn’t be a determining factor.”
Anderson called for an analysis of the costs and benefits to residents and urged the city to advertise vacancies.
“It’s no benefit at all to the taxpayers to have all these department heads on contracts because a mayor can come in, not this mayor, any mayor can come in and fire every department head,” Anderson said.
Commissioner Yesenia Baron asked why two of the agreements would waive the 25-year continuous-service requirement for a retiree health insurance benefit. The waivers would have applied to Brooks and Rivera-Sanchez, who were both hired before the program’s Jan. 1, 2011, cutoff. Both would still have had to meet the program’s other requirements.
Nesta estimated Brooks had about 24½ years of service and agreed with Baron that Rivera-Sanchez had 19. Nesta said Hippler had 33 years of service, already above the 25-year threshold.
Nesta said he had heard that the benefit had been used as leverage with employees in the past. He said he wanted directors to be able to do their jobs without feeling that the benefit was at risk.
During public comment, resident Kelvin Parks said a mayor should be able to assemble a leadership team and urged the city to open its hiring process to more applicants.
“As a leader, I have every right to build my team and put people around me whom I trust,” said Parks, a former hospital executive. “But I also interview so that I can select the people whom I trust.”
After the vote, Velazquez suggested working with human resources on employee protections through city policy. Nesta said he would continue updating the city’s personnel rules to address remote and hybrid work and flexible hours.


